Pricing Your NYC Condominium to Sell: Strategies and Tips

Pricing Your NYC Condominium to Sell: Strategies and Tips

Listing for Success: How to Price Your NYC Condo Competitively


In New York City, pricing your condominium for sale can seem like a daunting task. However, with the right strategies and insights, you can maximize your returns and ensure a swift and profitable transaction.

But how much of pricing is my responsibility as your broker?  This is the profession I have pursued for over 2o years now, and with that experience comes expertise.  Yes, most brokers have access to the same comps, but there’s more to it than that. 

It is your home, and your money, so the final decision is always yours as my client, but wouldn’t you like to have some insight into the process so that you can make more informed decisions?

Let’s dive into pricing NYC condominiums for success.

Understanding the Basics of Pricing a Condominium

Importance of Accurate Pricing

Setting the right price for your condo can be the difference between a rapid sale and lingering months on the market. Price it too high, and potential buyers may overlook your property; price it too low, and you leave money on the table.

Factors Influencing Condo Prices

Various factors can influence the price of your Manhattan or Brooklyn Condo. 

Some of these are objective, and some subjective factors.  This is where and why Dina’s and my experience shine to your benefit.

Location and Neighborhood

In real estate, location is everything. The neighborhood’s reputation, proximity to amenities, proximity of public transportation, congestion, and other location-specific factors play a crucial role in pricing.

Size and Layout

The square footage and layout of your condo will influence its price. Larger condos with open layouts typically fetch higher prices. 

PRO TIP: Size matters more the bigger you get

While it’s logical that the bigger the unit, the higher the price, what’s not so intuitive is that the progression isn’t linear.  The more rooms/bedrooms/baths you have, the greater the jump in value. 

For example, an 800 square foot one-bedroom may be worth 20% more than an 800 square foot studio apartment, but a 1,500 square foot three-bedroom may be worth 25% more than a two-bedroom apartment of the same size. 

The bigger the space, the higher the price per square foot (PPSF), and generally, the more rooms you have, the higher the price as well.

Building Amenities and Common Charges

Condos in buildings with attractive amenities such as a doorman, fitness center, or rooftop deck can command higher prices. However, higher common charges can offset these benefits.

What other sources don’t mention, but what we’ve learned first-hand is that all buyers are different.  There are condos with basketball and squash courts, pools, saunas, …etc.  On the face of it, they may seem more appealing. 

And to some buyers, yes, they are.  But in New York City, many people seek out private facilities for their recreation and have no interest in an indoor basketball court that they will never use. 

The point is that every apartment has a buyer, and it’s just a question of directing our efforts towards attracting that particular person. 

Don’t worry about what you can’t change about your building when selling.

Recent Market Trends

The real estate market’s health can significantly impact your condo’s price. In a seller’s market, you can price more aggressively, while in a buyer’s market, you may need to be more conservative.

No one wants a down market, but it’s vital to have a realistic understanding of what expectations are at any given time.  Once again, this is where our experience through all types of markets will really help.

Role of Comparative Market Analysis in Pricing

What is a Comparative Market Analysis?

A Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) is a tool real estate professionals use to determine a home’s market value based on similar, recently sold properties.

How to Conduct a Comparative Market Analysis A

 CMA involves finding similar properties in your area that have sold recently, comparing their features to your property, and adjusting the price accordingly. 

Virtually all real estate agents have access to databases to create these, but the skill comes in when deciding what qualifies as a comp and what doesn’t.  It’s not always obvious.

Interpreting Comparative Market Analysis

Results The CMA provides a range, not an exact figure. Your unique condo features, market conditions, and selling timeline can help fine-tune the pricing.

Again, the more qualified your broker is, the easier it will be to interpret the data.  Our job is more than running the numbers, it’s interpreting them for our clients. 

Working with Real Estate Professionals

How Real Estate Agents Assist in Pricing – And Why You Should Listen

Top notch real estate agents bring invaluable market knowledge, experience, expertise, and objective perspectives to help guide you with a realistic market price that accurately reflects the worth of your condo in the current market. 

We covered some of the reasons in earlier sections, but lets get a bit more into it here. 

Choosing the Right Real Estate Agent for Selling Your Home

Choose an agent familiar with NYC condos and the specific dynamics of your neighborhood. 

 They should have a track record of successful pricing strategies and sales.

You should like them.  You will be working with them, and you want to be compatible.

With over 40 years of combined experience, Dina and I bring you the expertise, market knowledge, and real-world sales experience needed to gain you the maximum result from your sale.  But beyond that, we’ve earned the trust of our clients.  One of our recent Manhattan condo sellers, Mary, recently said this:

“I’m thrilled that you and Dina got me such a great price, but I’m even more happy that you made the process easy.  I was scared to death to sell my home, but we went through everything before it happened, so I was emotionally ready for each step of the process.  With every little success along the way, I trusted you more, and become more confident that everything was going to be alright.  Thank you both so much!”

If you want to chat more about your situation, you can reach out to us anytime HERE.

The Art of Pricing: Beyond Numbers

Understanding Psychological Pricing Strategies

Strategies like how to position your property against similar units on the market, or pricing just under a natural search demarcation points can attract more potential buyers, and showcase your unit as the best deal for them.

Pricing Flexibility and Negotiations

Your initial price should leave some room for negotiations without straying too far from your desired sales price.

This concept alone is a topic too big for this article.  If you want to dive deeper, I’m happy to share my expertise with you. 

Dealing with Market Fluctuations

Impact of Market Conditions on Pricing

In a hot market, you can price more aggressively. In a slower market, competitive pricing and pricing ahead of the trending curve is the key to success.

Adjusting Your Price in a Changing Market

If your condo isn’t attracting offers, it’s essential to reassess your price. Being responsive to market changes can help secure a sale.

Common Pricing Mistakes to Avoid

Overpricing Your Condo

Overpricing can deter buyers and cause your condo to sit on the market, ultimately leading to a lower sales price.

PRO TIP: This is by far the most common pricing mistake sellers make.

Ignoring the Competition

Ignoring comparable condos in your area can result in mispricing. Stay aware of the competition.

Case Study: Karen’s golden unit


Karen owns a one-bedroom apartment in a 300+ unit building.  She loves her home, and thinks it’s very special.


The problem is that Karen thinks her unit is so special that it is worth 30% more than similar units in the very same building.  She refuses to listen to any evidence suggesting this is not the case.

The Turning Point

After a year on the market, and after having seen almost a dozen other units in her building come on the market, and sell, she finally had no real choice and agreed to lower the price. 


She sold the unit, but for a lower price than she would have received had she acted quickly when the market spoke loud and clear that she was priced too high.

Neglecting Necessary Repairs and Improvements

Neglecting necessary repairs and improvements can lower your condo’s perceived value and its final selling price.

Little repairs count too.  We had a buyer walk into a unit and open a kitchen cabinet.  The knob came off in her hand.  There was no coming back from that, and we moved on. 

Conclusion: Optimizing Your NYC Condo Pricing Strategy

Setting the right price for your NYC condo involves a mix of market knowledge, analysis, and strategy. Understand the factors influencing condo prices, utilize a Comparative Market Analysis, and work with real estate professionals to price your condo to sell. Be prepared to navigate market fluctuations and avoid common pricing pitfalls.

I hope I’ve been able to introduce you to some of the subtleties and inside “secrets” of how excellent brokers price your home effectively.

Where to next?

Continue on to the next article in the Selling Your NYC Condominium – A Step-by-Step Guide series: Marketing Your NYC Condo for Maximum Exposure. To return to the previous article in the series, click HERE.

You can jump directly to the main page for all of our informative articles concerning condominiums HERE.

Do you have any questions?  Feel free to reach out to Michael and Dina to discuss your situation with you and address any questions you may have about real estate. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):

What is the impact of overpricing my NYC condo?

Overpricing can lead to your condo lingering on the market, often resulting in lower offers as buyers may perceive the property as undesirable.

How does a Comparative Market Analysis help in pricing my condo?

A Comparative Market Analysis helps to determine your condo’s market value based on similar, recently sold properties. It gives you an understanding of what buyers are willing to pay for properties like yours.

What role does a real estate agent play in pricing my condo?

A real estate agent helps provide an objective perspective on your condo’s value, offers insights into the current market conditions, conducts a Comparative Market Analysis, and brings experience and expertise to the table.

How can I adjust my pricing strategy in response to market fluctuations?

Reacting swiftly to market changes is crucial. If your condo isn’t attracting offers or showings, it’s essential to reassess your price. Likewise, in a hot market, there may be an opportunity to increase your listing price.

What psychological pricing strategies can I employ when selling my NYC condo?

Strategies can include setting a psychologically palatable price just under a round number (e.g., pricing at $999,000 instead of $1M) and being sure to price your property near the top end of a natural search limit (e.g., pricing at $499,000 rather than $505,000 because people will generally search up to round numbers like $500k in this example)

Michael Sussilleaux

Michael Sussilleaux

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

M: 917.647.1464

Dina Sussilleaux

Dina Sussilleaux

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

M 917.324.6158